The Dawn of Computer-Graded Essays

USA Today recently reported the results of a study conducted in the United States to determine whether automated essay-scoring computer software can accurately grade student essays. After using the software to analyze 17,500 papers, the results concluded that the software is in fact capable of doing this. A small number of teachers already use computer-aided scoring, and as the technology becomes increasingly feasible and available, there is every chance that its use will become widespread across the United States and Canada. The question we are faced with is: Is this a good thing?
For teachers, essay grading takes time, and as a result of this, students can only receive so much writing feedback from their teachers per year. With this in mind, it seems that a major advantage to implementing essay-grading software is that students will be able to receive much quicker feedback for their written assignments. The period of time it takes a teacher to properly grade a written assignment can place limitations on the amount of writing experience that students can attain in school. Essay-grading software can remove some of these limitations. And even though the software can only grade students on technical writing skills, its existence could mean that students may spend more time actually writing—and we all know that the best way to master a skill is to practice. The technology will also potentially take some work off of the teachers’ plates, giving them more time to focus on helping students develop their ideas.
However, while essay-grading software can remove certain educational limitations, it must be remembered that the technology does create its own limitations as well. A computer can judge an essay on its technical merits, but it can’t really determine whether or not the essay has a unique writing style, or whether it presents sophisticated ideas. This kind of feedback is critical for students who wish to become truly great writers and at this point, such feedback can only be delivered when the essay is read by a human audience.
Perhaps the best approach here is ultimately to combine the human approach with the computer approach. In such a combined approach, a computer could grade the technical aspects of a paper, so that teachers could spend their time focusing on the writing style, and the ideas that are presented in that paper. In this way, the new technology will not replace the human element, but could assist it.
Do you think that computer graded essays are a good thing?
This post uses information from:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/story/2012-04-23/essay-scoring-computer-software/54493662/1